Page 1 of 1

Choose A Specific Backlink When Requesting A Trade?

Posted: Fri Jul 02, 2010 2:55 pm
by Maccsta
Maybe I’m missing something but is there any way to choose the exact backlink you want to give back when you request a trade?

At the moment you can only choose which sites you will gives links back on by PR.

Be great feature to add in.

Re: Choose A Specific Backlink When Requesting A Trade?

Posted: Fri Jul 02, 2010 3:38 pm
by inkognito
You can leave address with comment and if trader choose anything else for return you can decide to deny or accept trade.

Sometimes trader can use other address for his backlink than you mean, but that can be acceptable for both.

Re: Choose A Specific Backlink When Requesting A Trade?

Posted: Fri Jul 02, 2010 4:48 pm
by Maccsta
inkognito wrote:You can leave address with comment and if trader choose anything else for return you can decide to deny or accept trade.

Sometimes trader can use other address for his backlink than you mean, but that can be acceptable for both.
Hey inkognito. Yeah that's what I was planning to do, but it would be good to see it built into the trade system.

Re: Choose A Specific Backlink When Requesting A Trade?

Posted: Fri Jul 02, 2010 4:50 pm
by inkognito
On this way you have much more choice.

Re: Choose A Specific Backlink When Requesting A Trade?

Posted: Fri Jul 02, 2010 5:04 pm
by Maccsta
Well I'm not saying get rid of the message system when requesting a trade, just to add the feature to specify the backlink you are willing to give back.

That would save having to add a message each time.

Re: Choose A Specific Backlink When Requesting A Trade?

Posted: Wed Jul 07, 2010 4:12 am
by vrocks
I usually deny these kinds of trades since I might be looking for a backlink into my new anal site and you decide to offer me a link from a softcore babe site.

Re: Choose A Specific Backlink When Requesting A Trade?

Posted: Wed Jul 21, 2010 10:00 am
by alessandro
I was looking for a feature like this as well. Also, maybe be able to select yourself several sites from your own portofolio destined for the other webmaster to choose from when requesting a trade. For certain sites, I want to make sure I'll link out to certain niche, while some guys request links to totally different niches.

Re: Choose A Specific Backlink When Requesting A Trade?

Posted: Wed Jul 21, 2010 9:56 pm
by jdoughs
I don't think that there is a big issue to add this, and we've talked about it before on here. My main point I always try to make in this discussion is seasoned traders, will DENY most trades you send this way.

As VRocks says above, he usually deletes these types of trades in other systems. And so do I, I log in, check my requests, and delete ALL trades where the other webmaster has specified his links.

Why do I do this? Because historically every one of those trades has been ridiculous, or something I'm just not interested in.

Just some food for thought, you won't get more trades this way.

Re: Choose A Specific Backlink When Requesting A Trade?

Posted: Thu Jul 22, 2010 12:25 pm
by redwhiteandblue
On the other hand, quite often less experienced traders will request a link back to the site I am requesting a link from, turning what I wanted to be an ABCD trade into an ABC one. The problem being that I have sites on different servers linked in certain ways, so adding an ABC trade often would upset the link structure I have. So I have to then deny the trade, even though I was the one who initiated it.

Perhaps an option to prevent the other trader from requesting a link from or to either of the sites in the initial request would be useful? Or, perhaps have your sites allocated to groups which you set up, and then can offer the other trader only the sites in a certain group to link from?

Re: Choose A Specific Backlink When Requesting A Trade?

Posted: Thu Jul 22, 2010 8:58 pm
by Relentless
redwhiteandblue wrote:On the other hand, quite often less experienced traders will request a link back to the site I am requesting a link from, turning what I wanted to be an ABCD trade into an ABC one. The problem being that I have sites on different servers linked in certain ways, so adding an ABC trade often would upset the link structure I have. So I have to then deny the trade, even though I was the one who initiated it. Perhaps an option to prevent the other trader from requesting a link from or to either of the sites in the initial request would be useful? Or, perhaps have your sites allocated to groups which you set up, and then can offer the other trader only the sites in a certain group to link from?
The best option may well be to just get them on ICQ and tell them what you want.
I've done that with several people on LS and it has worked out very well.

Re: Choose A Specific Backlink When Requesting A Trade?

Posted: Sat Jul 31, 2010 2:57 pm
by cyberdog
I am for this option too.

Re: Choose A Specific Backlink When Requesting A Trade?

Posted: Wed Aug 11, 2010 8:14 pm
by venril
That would be a great feature to offer them a list of sites rather than just one site. For example, when I ask a link from their subfolder/subdomain site, I'd like to also offer them similar sites.

A good trader would always offer more than just one site in fear of possible rejection.

Re: Choose A Specific Backlink When Requesting A Trade?

Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2010 8:29 pm
by jdoughs
venril wrote:That would be a great feature to offer them a list of sites rather than just one site. For example, when I ask a link from their subfolder/subdomain site, I'd like to also offer them similar sites.

A good trader would always offer more than just one site in fear of possible rejection.

Good thinking, this would be much more effective then just attempting to offer 1 site in return (which are high % denials).